m loves peanut butter so when i found this place, i knew we had to try it. located in the middle of hip and young in nyc by new york university, it caters to the young at heart of all ages. there were so many choices – from different flavor peanut butter, to different sandwich creations with peanut butter, to drinks with peanut butter. then there’s peanut butter pie and peanut butter ice cream sundae. yum!
m ordered the mighty maple sandwich which included their mighty maple peanut butter and bacon. i ordered the black and tan with crunchy peanut butter and dark chocolate syrup. i loved both sandwiches. most impressive was the peanut butter – great flavor but not too sweet. pretty amazing!
since we were here, i wanted to try all of their different peanut butter flavors so i ordered their sampler but by the time i had my sandwich, i was too full! so, i brought it home and served it at an appetizer the next day. i think my favorite flavors are mighty maple and dark chocolate peanut butter. it’s okay to be nutty every now and then — especially when there is peanut butter involved.